Because This, is not a Competition


image

Sunday was World’s Women’s day, and I was quite pleased to see that one of the foremost items on the women’s agenda all over the world was the #BringBackOurGirls movement, referring to the 239 girls that were kidnapped from Chibok, Borno State, Nigeria  by terrorist group Boko Haram. In a nation where the people are reputed to be plagued with short memories, it is something pleasing to see that nearly a year after they were kidnapped, the dream that one day all the Chibok  girls will be found, is still being kept alive.

While I was reading about the #BBOG movement, I found myself thinking back to another Blog post that I read on the one year anniversary of the Buni Yadi massacre, where 59 boys were killed by Boko Haram on the 25th of February 2014 in  Federal Government College, Buni Yadi, Yobe state. The writer of the blog was arguing along the lines of   the Buni Yadi killings not getting as much attention as the Chibok kidnappings because the victims in Buni Yadi were boys instead of girls. As if they don’t deserve as much sympathy. While the writer was essentially correct, in truth Buni Yadi did not get as much attention as Chibok, but I felt he was going about it in an asshole manner. He was simply trying to imply that the media is more partial to the suffering of girls than of boys.

    Some weeks after I read the Buni Yadi massacre blog post, and on a totally unrelated note, I was reading a website where a man was sharing his experience of being raped by a woman. He confessed that the most difficult and surprising thing in the whole episode was not that his male friends did not believe he was raped; it was that the women he turned to for advice, simply spouted off statistics to show him that he had no right to complain because women have it worse than men when it comes to rape.

This set me to wondering why this is so. Female rights activists try to dismiss female on male rape, because male or female rape is more common. Male activists try to downplay male on female domestic abuse by bringing out statistics to show occurrences of female on male domestic abuse. Heterosexual people dismiss homosexual rape because heterosexual rape is a more pressing issue. Let an Asian raise concerns over white on Asian racism, and you will see people shooting him down with stats of White on Black racism.  Perhaps it is the “the world is a cruel place and only your team has got your back” mentality. The “team” in this case could be people that look most like you in age, gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, social class among others.  The cruel world mentality makes us think of everything in terms of resources that must be competed for. Wars have been fought over resources, over territory, over skin colour, so there is the tendency for us as people to think that other people are generally assholes who only care for things that matter to them, and that empathy as well as the ability to feel it, are resources that must be doled out to only people who share our condition. It is generally believed that those who are not careful about giving out sympathy freely like social workers soon become jaded, as their ability to sympathize with others run out like oil. The result of the cruel world mentality is a quest for groups to try to show themselves as most deserving of sympathy in order to collect and hoard the scarce resource of empathy, while regarding other groups as competitors who must be put down as fiercely as possible.  It is a manifestation of the “me/my team” mentality. We feel that any other group having the same problems that we do is somehow a deduction from our own uniqueness, and that is not good for our ego at all

    The world certainly as enough resources to compete for right now, oil, territory, religious freedoms, racial equality etc.  It will really be really sad for  humanity if we have to compete for the most basic of human resources, the ability to sympathize with others, the ability to feel pain, to put ourselves in someone else’s shoes. Men are as guilty of this as feminists, atheists are as guilty of this as religious people, and black people are as guilty of this as white people. Empathy is not a resource to be fought over, the goal of the world must be to ensure that every underdog, everybody in pain, everybody who is suffering, has a chance to express themselves without being looked down on or hounded. This is why I am pleased with the #BringBackOurGirls movement. In spite of the latent animosity between Northern and Southern Nigeria in recent years , it is pleasing that #BBOG is no longer a Northern Nigerian problem, it is not even a Nigerian issue anymore, it is an issue the whole world is speaking strongly about.  Issues like #BBOG, #JeSuischarlie have come to prove than the world can lay aside its divides and sympathize free with the suffering of a group of people proving that empathy need not be a resource to be hoarded, because this… is not a competition.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Because This, is not a Competition

  1. The point of this piece just keeps roaming everywhere…difficult to grab.

    Yes, there is female-on-male rape. Yes, it is not acknowledged or as loud as male-on-female rape is. Yes, there is more male-on-female rape out there.

    Yes, it is more about lack of stats, male rape is less, much less reported than female rape which is itself under-reported. Yes, it will even be more difficult to establish. Imagine the challenges of establishing a male-on-female rape? Now imagine how challenging female on male rape would be…how do you prove it: bruises on the penis? A penis hardly speaks. Or videos: that could mean you prepared for it; it was pre-empted thus may not be rape? All sorts of issues. I do not undermine female-on-male rape, just the issues.

    Also look at it like this: it is more damning or many men would consider it more damning to report that they have been raped? It is “supposed” to be a patriarchal society anyway…

    No, it is not a function of a resource battle. It is more psychological, more about the nature of the society, than any other thing. Methinks.

    Please provide link to the story about the female-on-male rape.

    Also editing your article would make it more readable. And together, we can address issues better, #bringbackourgirls and rape, of any kind.

    1. First of all thanks for reading. The editing will be looked at as you have suggested. However if it looks like the piece is going everywhere, as you noted, that’s precisely because I didn’t intend for it to take a position . The article is not about rape per se, the rape instance is just an example of how people fail to sympathize with others because they feel theirs is the greater suffering which is why I brought in the Chibok and the Buni Yadi example. The piece is not arguing about who is wrong or who is right, it is about not treating other people’s suffering like a competition. The rape article you requested can be found at http://www.cracked.com/article_21884_5-awful-realities-being-man-who-was-raped-by-woman.html

  2. I totally get your point bro! Everyone should take a position not as feminists, atheists, bla bla bla, but as humans concerned about the plight of the underdog and determined to fight injustice to anyone. These separation of causes are precisely what has hampered progress against many injustices. Sure, we should have positions and passions but in the end, we should not particularise our problems. Rather, we should team up and have a common front against any form of inhumanity!

    Missed seeing your hand here. Welcome back!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s